PopupBuilder.io

Comparison

Popupsmart VS OptiMonk Comparison

The verdict

Popupsmart and OptiMonk do the same job on paper: pageview-metered popups, Shopify, a free plan, a wheel. OptiMonk is cheaper to start and includes tests on Free. Popupsmart is the simpler Shopify install and three sites on Basic.

Published January 18, 2023 · Last reviewed August 29, 2026

Popupsmart and OptiMonk at a glance

Popupsmart

$32.50

Basic, per month, billed annually

Free tier
Free plan
Metered on
Monthly pageviews

OverviewPricingReview

OptiMonk

$29

Essential, per month

Free tier
Free plan
Metered on
Monthly pageviews

OverviewPricingReview

Popupsmart checked August 2026; OptiMonk checked August 2026. Both vendors change prices without notice — confirm on their own pages before you buy.

Who each one is for

Reasons to pick one over the other, taken from each tool's profile — not a feature-by-feature scorecard.

Choose Popupsmart if

Shopify stores and small sites that want a working popup the same day, with a real free plan and gamification included.

  • Free plan is usable: 5K pageviews, one live popup, no card required
  • Shopify app rates 4.8/5 from 50 reviews with a one-click install
  • Spin-to-win and lottery-ball gamification ship on every plan
  • Unlimited live popups from the first paid plan

Skip Popupsmart if

  • A/B testing starts only on Advanced ($57.50/mo billed annually)
  • Free plan has no analytics, one website, and a 5K pageview cap
  • Pageview overage is $10 per extra 10K when auto-extend is on
  • Reviewers still report domain verification taking more than one try

Choose OptiMonk if

Ecommerce stores that want spin-to-win and other gamified campaigns, plus a Klaviyo-ready capture layer, without paying extra for those campaign types.

  • Gamified campaign types (lucky wheel, pick-a-gift, scratchcard) ship on every plan
  • Free plan covers 10,000 pageviews with A/B testing and unlimited campaigns
  • Support scores 9.7/10 on G2; live chat is advertised under 3 minutes
  • Shopify app rated 4.8 from 420 reviews as of August 2026

Skip OptiMonk if

  • Billed on all site pageviews, not campaign impressions, so cost jumps with traffic
  • Template styling still needs trial and error, per recent G2 reviews
  • Mobile exit-intent needs a separate setup and is less reliable than desktop
  • After Essential, the next self-serve jump is Growth at $99 a month

What G2 reviewers mention

Pulled from each product's G2 reviews page. We do not turn these into a score.

Popupsmart

Reviewers like

  • Users appreciate the ease of use of Popupsmart, making pop-up creation quick and stress-free without coding. (54 mentions)
  • Users praise the easy setup of Popupsmart, appreciating the quick configuration and seamless website integration. (26 mentions)
  • Users appreciate the wide range of integrations in Popupsmart, enhancing lead generation and ease of use. (18 mentions)
  • Users value the audience growth enabled by Popupsmart, effectively building a loyal customer base through tailored popups. (15 mentions)
  • Users highlight the intuitive interface of Popupsmart, making it easy to navigate and utilize effectively. (15 mentions)

Reviewers push back

  • Users express a need for more templates and features to enhance their popup experience and flexibility. (16 mentions)
  • Users find the upgrade costs expensive, particularly challenging for small websites with tighter budgets. (10 mentions)
  • Users find the limited customization options of Popupsmart's popups somewhat restrictive and lacking design flexibility. (6 mentions)
  • Users face integration issues with Popupsmart, particularly when connecting to systems like Storyblok, which can be time-consuming. (5 mentions)
  • Users find the poor analytics limiting, wishing for more advanced insights into popup performance and engagement. (4 mentions)

From G2 reviews of Popupsmart, collected August 2026. These are G2's own words, not our ranking.

OptiMonk

Reviewers like

  • Users appreciate the ease of campaign creation with OptiMonk, enjoying user-friendly templates and efficient setup. (2 mentions)
  • Users commend the ease of creation of campaigns with OptiMonk, enhancing their overall marketing experience. (2 mentions)
  • Users find the ease of use of OptiMonk's campaign creation tools to be highly convenient and efficient. (2 mentions)
  • Users find the easy creation of campaigns with OptiMonk highly convenient and user-friendly after initial setup. (2 mentions)

Reviewers push back

  • Users find the difficult setup challenging, especially when targeting specific pages to conserve pageviews effectively. (1 mention)
  • Users find it difficult with editing issues, particularly when trying to change colors and fonts effectively. (1 mention)
  • Users find integration with Emarsys challenging, particularly when targeting specific pages due to pageview limitations. (1 mention)
  • Users face integration issues with OptiMonk, particularly regarding setup with Emarsys and pageview constraints. (1 mention)
  • Users find the lack of API integration with Emarsys to be disappointing and complicating their setup needs. (1 mention)

From G2 reviews of OptiMonk, collected August 2026. These are G2's own words, not our ranking.

Popupsmart and OptiMonk do the same job on paper: pageview-metered popups, Shopify, a free plan, a wheel. OptiMonk is the personalisation product. Popupsmart is the simpler Shopify install.

Popupsmart Basic is $32.50/mo billed annually for 50,000 pageviews and three sites (popupsmart.com/pricing, 29 August 2026). OptiMonk Essential is $29/mo or $19/mo billed yearly ($228) for 20,000 pageviews (optimonk.com/pricing). Our 2023 copy had OptiMonk Essential at $39 and Free at 15,000 pageviews. Current Free is 10,000 pageviews with A/B tests.

Popupsmarrt vs OptiMonk comparison on a fair background

Popupsmart vs OptiMonk at a glance

Popupsmart OptiMonk
Meter Site pageviews Site pageviews
Free plan 5k pageviews, 1 live popup, no A/B 10k pageviews, unlimited campaigns, A/B on Free
Starting paid Basic $32.50/mo yearly (50k, 3 sites) Essential $29/mo or $19 yearly (20k, 2 domains)
A/B testing Advanced ($57.50 yearly) and up On Free
Gamification Spin-to-win, lottery, surprise box on every plan Lucky wheel, pick-a-gift, scratchcard on every plan
Shopify Embed app, 4.8/5 from 50 reviews Native app, 4.8/5 from 420 reviews

Sources: both vendor pricing pages, 29 August 2026.

Who wins on price?

OptiMonk, to start.

Yearly Essential is $19/mo for 20,000 pageviews. Popupsmart Basic is $32.50 for 50,000 and three sites. If you need the extra quota and extra sites on one paid rung, Popupsmart can be the better bill. If you want to try a wheel at $0 with tests, OptiMonk Free wins. Popupsmart Free has no tests.

Overage: Popupsmart is $10 per extra 10,000 pageviews with auto-extend. OptiMonk sells the next step inside Essential (30k, 50k) before you jump to Growth at $99 / $69 yearly.

Who wins on gamification?

Neither, if the brief is "a wheel that collects an email." Both ship it.

OptiMonk wins if the brief is "a wheel, then a recommendation, then a different offer by country." That is the product they sell. Popupsmart's SiteData and Smart Mode can approximate some of that; they are targeting features, not a personalisation layer.

Who should pick which?

Popupsmart if you want a Shopify app you can install without a call, three sites on Basic, and you will not run tests until you are sure the format works.

OptiMonk if on-site personalisation is the job, or you want tests before you pay. The extra campaign types are a different product, not a nicer popup.

Does OptiMonk still start at $39?

No. Essential is $29/mo or $19/mo billed yearly on optimonk.com/pricing (29 August 2026). The $39 figure was this site's January 2023 note.

Related: Popupsmart pricing, OptiMonk pricing, Popupsmart alternatives.

Related comparisons

Written and reviewed by

Emel Dalabasmaz
Emel Dalabasmaz

SEO Executive at Flatart

Emel Dalabasmaz graduated in Advertising and Public Relations from Anadolu University. She began in social media and carried that grounding — content, brand communication and performance — into SEO. For more than ten years she has worked on growth for brands across a range of industries, pairing a communications perspective with data and technical analysis to build a digital presence that holds up over time.

Education
Advertising and Public Relations, Anadolu University
Writes about
Popup builders, Conversion rate optimization, On-site messaging, SaaS pricing research, SEO, Technical SEO, Content strategy, Digital marketing