Popupsmart and Poptin both offer free entry points, but their traffic allowances measure different things. Popupsmart Basic costs $390 annually for 50,000 monthly pageviews and three websites. Poptin Basic costs $25 monthly or $240 annually for 10,000 monthly visitors and one domain. The lower annual price does not establish which allowance will last longer on your website.
Popupsmart vs Poptin at a glance
| Decision | Popupsmart | Poptin |
|---|---|---|
| Entry paid annual total | Basic: $390 | Basic: $240 |
| Entry paid traffic allowance | 50,000 monthly pageviews | 10,000 monthly visitors |
| Entry paid site allowance | Three websites | One domain |
| Free traffic allowance | 5,000 pageviews | 1,000 visitors on one domain |
| Testing budget | A/B testing starts at Advanced, $690 annually | Check the popup plan comparison against your required testing workflow |
| Email scope | Check the email quota and destination workflow separately | Popup-only and Emails & Poptins are distinct offerings |
Sources: Popupsmart pricing and Poptin pricing, checked 5 September 2026. Annual prices are commitments, not month-to-month charges. Popupsmart’s free live-campaign entitlement needs confirmation because its pricing and homepage messaging differ.
Which traffic allowance fits your website?
Suppose your forecast is 8,000 monthly visitors generating 40,000 pageviews on one website. Both Basic allowances fit those figures. At 12,000 visitors and 36,000 pageviews, the forecast exceeds Poptin Basic’s visitor allowance while remaining within Popupsmart Basic’s pageview allowance. At 9,000 visitors and 54,000 pageviews, the reverse applies.
These are worked budgeting examples, not measured product results. Reconcile your analytics definitions with each vendor’s billing meter before buying; repeated visits, browser identification and script coverage can affect the count. Do not compare 10,000 visitors with 50,000 pageviews as if they were the same unit.
What changes when you manage several websites?
Popupsmart Basic includes three websites, whereas Poptin Basic includes one domain. Poptin Pro lists four domains and a printed annual total of $564. For a three-site brief, comparing only the two Basic prices misses the domain requirement. Traffic capacity and campaign features still need a separate check.
For client work, also verify who can access each account and whether reporting and subscriber data stay separated. Domain capacity alone does not establish an agency permission model. See Poptin pricing for the unresolved difference between its management wording and subaccount FAQ.
Do you need popup capture or email sending too?
Poptin now presents a separate Emails & Poptins offering. Its combined Free card lists 250 active contacts, 500 emails, 1,000 monthly popup visitors and one domain. Those are independent limits. The popup-only Basic price is not a quote for a complete email marketing replacement.
If you already use an email platform, start with the capture workflow: submit a test address, verify its destination list and custom properties, then check consent and the follow-up message. If you intend to send inside Poptin, forecast active contacts and sends as well as website visitors. Its current-cycle active-contact count includes contacts that were subscribed or unconfirmed earlier in that cycle, even if later unsubscribed.
How should you choose?
Shortlist Poptin when its visitor allowance and popup-only price fit a single-domain brief. Shortlist Popupsmart when the pageview allowance and three-site Basic entitlement fit your requirements. If A/B testing is essential, budget for Popupsmart Advanced rather than Basic and verify the matching Poptin workflow before comparing totals.
A useful trial should prove the complete path from display to subscriber destination on desktop and mobile. Record targeting, dismissal behavior, field mapping and the billing meter. These checks support a decision; an app rating or a platform name alone does not demonstrate a better fit.
Related: Popupsmart pricing, Poptin pricing, Popupsmart integrations, Poptin integrations.
